Showing posts with label p fluorochemicals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label p fluorochemicals. Show all posts

23 Jun 2008

Pizza boxes in the news - DIBP concerns

Pizza boxes are in the news again, this time because of concerns that those manufactured with recycled paper may contain di-isobutyl phthalate (DIBP). In the Telegraph.co.uk article, it is stated that, 'According to the Food Standards Agency [DIBP] may have a harmful affect on human reproductive development because they have been reported to be endocrine (hormone) disrupters.'

That there is some DIBP in certain types of paper is not questioned, after all, scientists in the home of the pizza (University of Milan) found traces of DIBP in boxes from 16 different restaurants in northern Italy. One box contained more than 70 micrograms, and several had more than 40 micrograms.

DIBP can originate from the inks (certain printing processes), glues and colourants found in certain grades of recycled paper and board.

So what is the exposure and risk to human health? Probably very little. There is an ongoing debate as to whether packaging used in contact with food should be made for virgin rather than recycled paper as the latter often contains chemicals which have not been tested and approved for food contact use. Countries rich in wood fibre (eg Finland) usually argue the case for using virgin fibre, whereas those with larger populations and an abundance of recycled fibre have an interest in using recycled fibre (eg France) in packaging paper and board.

The pizza box has also been in the news for containing PFOS and PFOA, the harmful by-products found in many fluorochemicals used to give grease resistance. Pizza box manufacturers have made big strides to stop the use of these fluorochemicals but suppliers are still offering the products to the industry for food-contact use.

16 Jun 2008

Fluorochemicals used in paper and packaging - is the new C6 chemistry an advance on the problematic C8?

To the many of you who read the earlier blog on fluorochemicals and their use in paper, and any others with an interest in this topic, it may be worth reading the recent article by the Environmental Working Group (EWG).

EWG, 'Finds no evidence that the industry-touted replacement chemicals being rushed to market are safer -- and plenty of evidence that DuPont and other manufacturers are continuing a decades-long pattern of deception about the health risks of PFOA and related chemicals.'

EWG make the point that the move from C8 to C6 chemistry is,

'Greenwashing – claiming environmental benefits for a product that's little better than its replacement – at its worst. PFOA is so remarkably persistent in the environment and broadly toxic to living organisms that using it as a bar against which to judge "green chemistry" is like calling anything under 200 miles per hour a safe speed limit. For C6 replacements, the full extent of the public record on their safety consists of a PowerPoint presentation delivered by Asahi Glass Company to the Environmental Protection Agency. Public records show that DuPont, Asahi, and Clariant are all shifting from PFOA to C6 chemistries despite an absolute dearth of public safety data, and despite the fact that on 3 critical counts, C6 may be as great a concern as PFOA:

  • C6, like all the other PFCs, is extraordinarily persistent in the environment (NAS 1972).
  • C6 is potentially 3 to 5 times more toxic than C8 to aquatic organisms (Asahi 2006).
  • C6 crosses the placenta to contaminate children before birth, according to an EWG study of umbilical cord blood from 10 newborn babies (EWG 2005). While many studies of thousands of people by CDC, industry, and academic university researchers show that PFOA contaminates nearly the entire U.S. population, industry has failed to publish even a single study of C6 in people. EWG's tests of cord blood show it to be potentially as great a concern as PFOA.
EWG certainly make some good points in amongst the sometimes emotive and hyperbolic writing. The fact remains, does it make sense to continue with fluorine chemistry? Surely this is an opportunity to develop and market fluorine-free alternatives.

The main companies involved in the manufacture and supply (directly or indirectly) of fluorine-based chemicals to the paper industry are: Arkema, Asahi, Ciba, Clariant, Daikin, DuPont, 3M/Dyneon and Solvay Solexis. There are others.

Fluorine-based chemicals are mainly used in paper and packaging to give grease-resistance (eg pizza boxes, burger wrap, butter wrap, soap wrap, pet-food bags). Alternative barriers are available for some of the current applications, but in some of the more demanding applications it has been difficult to find chemicals which perform as well as those containing fluorine with its unique physical properties. Finding fluorine-free alternatives is an opportunity.

9 Jun 2008

Topchim introduces new biopolymer as a wax substitute for packaging

Topchim (Antwerp, Belgium) has announced the introduction of an environmental friendly, patented, nano-dispersed biopolymer as a substitute for wax emulsions in producing super hydrophobic paper and cardboard packaging.

As Topchim state, 'The packaging industry is seeking easy recyclable and environmental friendly packaging solutions made of renewable resources. TopChim ........ has developed an innovative biopolymer as a competitive, ecological substitute for wax emulsions used in the coating production of hydrophobic paper and board packaging. This 2-year research program has resulted in a new coating technology for paper and cardboard that counters the disadvantages of using wax emulsions while maintaining the excellent water barrier performances.'

What is it? The new biopolymer is of vegetable origin, while most used wax emulsions are produced from petrochemicals; it is biopolymer with a monodisperse size-distribution of nano-particles with a regular shape; and, it is reported to show other important advantages for the surface treatment of paper and cardboard compared to the use of wax emulsions:

  • requires no stabilizers even with a high solid content
  • viscosity remains low (65% solids at +/- 300 cps with Brookfield 23°C 100 rpm spindle 5)
  • coating machines can simply be rinsed with water
  • has a higher temperature resistance and is less sticky, which improves the handling of the treated paper and cardboard in production.

Marketed as TopScreen DS13, it is approved for a wide variety of paper and board coating applications, both in-line and off-machine.

TopScreen DS13 will be introduced during the second half of 2008 in Europe and South America. TopChim has a total production capacity of 10,000 tons at 2 plants in Europe with plans to invest in additional production capacity in South America.

The announcement highlights the opportunity to replace wax but does not mention opportunities to replace fluorochemicals where paper and packaging companies continue to look for fluorine-free alternatives. See one of the earlier blogs, or look at all our related blogs by clicking on the drop-down menu on the right hand side --> 'blog topics', 'p fluorochemicals'.

PFOS, PFOA, bioaccumulation, Canda International

5 Mar 2008

California first to introduce a bill to ban the introduction of PFCs into food packaging - Why are they alone?

At last there has been a move somewhere in the world to challenge the lengthy, voluntary withdrawal of the use of fluorochemicals containing PFCs from use in applications such as food packaging. This topic has been covered before in this weblog and the question asked as to why there should be a voluntary agreement with the EPA to withdraw these products when there is clear evidence that they are harmful.

See the weblog on the EPA announcement that the big manufacturers are on track, or that on the recent DuPont study to produce evidence as to the fate of fluorochemicals in the environment.

The question remains, why wait until 2015? In many papermaking applications there are alternatives, but if there are not, then increased pressure will generate innovation.

Enviroblog covers this topic well and highlights the recent bill filed by California State Senator Ellen M. Corbett which would make California the first state to ban some PFCs in food packaging. The bill, sponsored by EWG, would prohibit more than trace amounts of two PFCs called PFOS and PFOA in any material used to package food, beginning in 2010.

The big producers working with the EPA include Arkema, Asahi, Ciba, Clariant, Daikin, DuPont, 3M/Dyneon and Solvay Solexis.

4 Feb 2008

EPA announces that big PFOA releasers are on track

The EPA has announced that eight major companies have reported significant drops in the release of PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid) and related chemicals, putting industry on target to meet a 95 percent reduction goal in PFOA emissions and product content by 2010. Further reductions are anticipated by 2015.

The chemical companies include Arkema, Asahi, Ciba, Clariant, Daikin, DuPont, 3M/Dyneon and Solvay Solexis. In an earlier post the question was raised as to why it takes so long to stop selling products containing PFOA or PFOA precursors especially in paper and packaging where alternative, fluorine-free options are available.

More information on PFOA is at: epa.gov/opptintr/pfoa/index.htm

Company progress reports and EPA's summary tables are available at: epa.gov/oppt/pfoa/pubs/preports.htm

11 Jan 2008

Paper fluorochemicals and PFOA - new Du Pont study adds to debate on grease-resistance chemicals being source of PFOA

A recent publication by DuPont scientists adds to the current debate on whether paper chemicals (and other fluorotelomer-based products used in textiles, carpets etc) are a source of PFOA. This peer-reviewed report describes a long-term study of the degradation of perfluorinated polymers in soil. ES&T online have given a good review of the study and views on the validity of the conclusions and the opinions of key bodies such as the EPA.

The jury is still out:

  • PFOA has been shown to cause liver damage, reproductive problems, which has seen it labelled a “likely carcinogen” by the Environmental Protection Agency EPA's Science Advisory Board.
  • PFOA is bioaccumulative, has been found widely in the environment and is a big concern.
  • The DuPont study concludes that the PFOA and PFCAs come from impurities, also known as residuals or precursors, in the fluoropolymer product they tested (stain repellant solution). As a result, they conclude that the polymer degrades very slowly, with a half-life of 1200–1700 years and degrades too slowly to be a current source of PFOA in the environment. Others disagree with the conclusions and have raised a number of valid ponits regarding the interpretation of the results and conclusions drawn from the study.
Time for a quick summary of where the paper chemical supply industry is with perfluorinated chemicals (PFCs) such as PFOS (perfluorooctyl sulphonate) and PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid). Perfluorinated chemicals (PFCs), gained notoriety in the paper chemicals industry when in the late 1990's, 3M Corporation announced they would withdraw their successful Scotchban fluorochemicals from the market. These chemicals were sold for use in grease-resistant paper and board and it became clear that PFOS (perfluorooctyl sulphonate) was detected widely in the blood of humans - PFOS is a PFC and is classified as persistent, bioaccumulative and toxic (PBT). The details and history of PFOS are outlined on the EPA website or in a number of environmental-concern sites (eg EWG). Although the production of products containing PFOS has been stopped, ongoing blood sampling continues to reveal the presence of PFOS (eg WWF and The Co-operative Bank).

The
findings on PFOS led the EPA in 2000 to review similar chemicals, including PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid) to determine whether they might also present concerns. In essence, PFCs accumulate in the environment and have been found in a wide range of wildlife, as well as in humans. There is evidence to suggest that exposure to perfluorinated chemicals such as PFOS and PFOA may cause birth defects, adversely affect the immune system and disrupt thyroid function, which during pregnancy, can lead to many developmental problems (there are a number of references but for example see the WWF or the very effective Environmental Working Group's web sites). The US Environmental Protection Agency also considers both PFOS and PFOA to be carcinogenic and occupational exposure to PFOS has been correlated with increased incidence of bladder cancer.

The generation of PFOS was linked to the electrolytic process used by 3M and a Japanese manufaturer and it was known that the other process used by companies such as DuPont, called telomerisation would not generate PFOS. However, in producing a number of fluorine-based chemicals (not paper chemeicals), PFOA is used as a processing aid and later science showed how PFOA could be produced as an unintentional by-product.

Where are we now with the EPA investigation:

So, are paper chemical manufacturers and suppliers continuing to sell fluorochemicals containing PFCs or PFC precursors?
  • The answer is yes.
  • Trademarks of fluoropolymers used to give grease-resistance in the paper and board industry: Zonyl (DuPont), Lodyne (Ciba), Cartafluor (Clariant).
Many environmental-concern groups have worked hard to expose and bring an end to the release of PFOS and PFOA and significant pressure has been put on manufacturers to develop PFC-free alternatives. The big question is why, when it is known that PFOA is persitent, bioaccumulative and toxic, that its release into the environment is not stopped immediately. Reducing emissions between now and 2015 is at least a start.

Are there alternatives to PFC-containing products?
  • Fluorine is a unique compound with unique properties so changing to chemistries such as silicone bring a loss of performance. In some applications this lower level of performance could be sufficient. Solvay has an alternative to fluorine. In some applications it is possible to use barrier coatings based on latex formulations and/or waxes.
  • The smaller molecule, fluorosurfactant-based products were of immediate concern as they would be more likely to be adsorbed by animals. Therefore, an approach has been to favour higher molecular weight fluoropolymers. This does not necessarily remove the hazard as by-products can be generated in the manufacturing process and the polymer itself has the potential to degrade in the environment and generate PFOA (it was this hypothesis which the DuPont scientists were studying).
  • Some companies have put effort into C4 and C6 fluorotelomers rather than the traditional C8 chemistry with the view that the environmental and toxicological effects would be reduced. However, there have been no breakthroughs in producing cost-effective paper chemicals so far.
Some additional reading:
C&EN article
ACS article
CEE Food Industry Article

10 Jun 2007

Ciba announce recyclable alternative to traditional wax for corrugated boxes

With waxes (difficult to recycle) and fluorochemicals (PBT issues with PFOA and PFOS) rightly receiving bad press, there is pressure on paper and board companies to find new approaches to developing barrier properties.

In the news this last week was an announcement by Ciba Specialty Chemicals of wax replacement products for corrugated boxes. Ciba has signed an exclusive agreement with Spectra-Kote Corporation of Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, USA for the global marketing of Spectra-Kote’s line of wax-alternative materials (marketed as WAM products) which allow corrugated box makers to produce wax-free boxes that are both functional and environmentally friendly. WAM products waterproof solid boxboard, and unlike traditional waxed corrugated boxes, can be recycled, and are therefore attractive to fruit/vegetable growers and retailers.


WAM technology uses a combination of paper additives and specific papermaking processes.